In partnership with
When I started in the staffing industry, one of the first pieces of advice I heard from “seasoned” agency people was this:
“Avoid HR at all costs. They’re ****blocks.”
It was said with the same smug confidence as “work smarter, not harder.”
The idea was simple: HR blocks access to hiring managers. They enforce process. They make things harder than they need to be. They’ll stop you from making placements.
So, in agency land, HR was framed as the obstacle. The ones who got in your way.
But that advice? It’s the laziest mindset in recruiting.
Recruiters Love to Talk About Partnership. They Just Don’t Practice It.
Let’s be honest: a lot of recruiters talk about being “strategic partners,” but then immediately go behind HR’s back the moment it suits them.
They’ll DM hiring managers directly, flood inboxes with resumes, and justify it by saying “I’m just trying to get results.” They hope if they drop the perfect candidate in a hiring manager’s lap, they’ll be able to skip HR entirely.
It’s short-sighted. It burns trust. And it’s exactly why internal HR teams often don’t want to work with agencies in the first place.
Because the truth is, in an ideal world, recruiters and HR are supposed to be on the same side of the table.
The Real Dream Team
Here’s how it’s actually supposed to work:
HR owns the “why.”
They know the company’s goals, structure, and culture. They understand the internal dynamics that don’t show up on a job description.Recruiters own the “how.”
They know where to find the right people, how to approach them, and what the market actually looks like.
When those two perspectives combine, hiring stops being reactive. It becomes strategic.
HR can’t be everywhere at once, they’re managing compliance, culture, and a dozen other fires. Recruiters can’t build credibility inside the company overnight.
Together, though? You get clarity, speed, and accountability.
Let’s Be Clear: You Still Need Direct Access
Now, to be very clear: I’m not saying you don’t need direct lines of contact with hiring managers. You absolutely do.
That’s something I insist on for every intake call. It’s how you make sure everyone’s aligned on expectations, skill sets, and the story we’re telling to candidates.
Direct access is critical. But it only works when it’s built on trust.
When HR knows you’re not trying to go rogue (no pun intended), they’ll open that door for you. When they trust you to act as an extension of their team (not their competition) communication flows faster, approvals move quicker, and the process just works.
Partnership isn’t red tape. It’s trust that lets you move faster.
HR Isn’t the Problem. Your Approach Is.
If you’re a recruiter who’s spent your whole career trying to “work around” HR, that’s not rebellion. That’s laziness. And, you’re part of the problem.
It’s easy to blame HR for slowing things down. It’s harder to do the work to earn their trust.
When you actually partner with them, you get access to:
Real feedback about why past hires worked or didn’t.
A clear picture of internal expectations and pay ranges.
Early insight into new roles before they hit the market.
That kind of collaboration doesn’t just make your job easier; it makes you better.
What Great Partnership Looks Like
Some of the best relationships I’ve had in my career weren’t with hiring managers I “won over,” they were with HR pros who trusted me.
We were aligned on outcomes. We communicated often. We were honest about what was working and what wasn’t. We assumed good intentions when working together.
When that happens, recruiting stops being a tug-of-war and starts feeling like a relay.
You’re passing the baton, not pulling in opposite directions.
Here’s what it looks like in practice:
HR loops recruiters into the strategy early, not after they’re desperate to fill a seat.
Recruiters share data about the market.
Both sides respect each other’s process.
Everyone agrees that speed doesn’t mean chaos.
When that’s the dynamic, hiring actually works.
Why This Matters Right Now
Right now, the market is loud. Every week, another self-proclaimed “AI recruiter” pops up promising automation and shortcuts.
The reality is, the low barrier to entry in this industry means a lot of people jump in for quick money without learning what partnership looks like.
And HR feels that.
They get ghosted by agencies that disappear after sending a few resumes. They get “pipeline updates” that are really just excuses. They get spammed by recruiters who can’t even remember what role they’re working on.
So when I say HR has every right to be cautious, I mean it.
The good recruiters are outnumbered…not by talent, but by noise.
What I Tell My Team (and My Clients)
At Rogue, our job is to make HR’s job easier, not harder.
That means clear communication, structured updates, and mutual respect.
It means understanding that HR isn’t a “gatekeeper.” They’re the gate. If you don’t respect them, you’re not getting through it.
The best recruiters I know make HR look good.
The Takeaway
If you’re an external recruiter, stop treating HR like an obstacle.
If you’re in HR, stop working with transactional recruiters because you don’t think you have a choice.
You’re both after the same thing: to hire the right person, in the right way, without making everyone miserable in the process.
Recruiting is hard enough as it is. We don’t need turf wars. We need trust and respect.
See you next Monday,
Robin
#GoRogue
Your Boss Will Think You’re an Ecom Genius
If you’re optimizing for growth, you need ecomm tactics that actually work. Not mushy strategies.
Go-to-Millions is the ecommerce growth newsletter from Ari Murray, packed with tactical insights, smart creative, and marketing that drives revenue.
Every issue is built for operators: clear, punchy, and grounded in what’s working, from product strategy to paid media to conversion lifts.
Subscribe for free and get your next growth unlock delivered weekly.